Skip to content

When a Bug Becomes a Win-Back Campaign: Turning Problems Into Revenue

A Google sign-in bug locked out 137 shoppers. We fixed the root cause, then turned the mistake into a win-back email that brought customers back.

Published 4 min readModulyth Systems

The Bug That Lost Customers

A service business client called us when their shoppers started complaining. People who tried to sign in with Google were stuck in a loop: click the button, authorize Google, land back on the homepage signed out. Try again, same result.

The root cause was a mismatch in authentication settings. The system expected sign-in redirects to land on one version of the domain, but the live site sent shoppers to another. When the redirect did not match the allowed list, the authentication service silently sent people to the wrong page. The sign-in code never reached the handler, so the session never started. Every shopper who hit that button was turned away.

Over two weeks, 137 people tried and failed. Most did not try again. They left, and the client lost orders.

Fixing the Root Cause First

Before we could win anyone back, we had to make sure sign-in worked. We corrected the allowed redirect list so both domain versions were recognized. We added a safety net that forwarded stray authentication codes to the right handler. We stored the shopper's intended destination in a short-lived cookie so they would land on their cart, not the homepage, after signing in.

We tested the fix with real Google sign-ins on the live site. No loops. No silent failures. Sign-in worked.

Only then did we turn to the 137 people who had been locked out.

Turning the Bug Into a Campaign

We pulled the list of affected shoppers from sign-in records. We excluded anyone who had placed an order since the bug started (they had found another way in). We excluded unsubscribes and anyone on the suppression list. That left 92 people who had tried to sign in, failed, and had not come back.

The client approved a short apology email. It acknowledged the problem, explained that sign-in now worked, and included a small discount code as a gesture. The email was plain and honest. No hype, no long story, just the facts and a reason to try again.

We built a simple admin page to manage the send. The client could preview the email, send a test copy to herself, and trigger the real send in batches. Nothing went out automatically. She stayed in control.

What We Learned About Win-Back Work

Win-back emails are not just for lapsed customers. They work for anyone who tried to do business with you and could not. A broken sign-in is the same as a locked door. People walked up, found it stuck, and left. Once you fix the door, you have to tell them it opens now.

The list matters. We only reached out to people who had actually been affected and had not returned. Sending to the wrong group would have wasted their time and hurt trust.

Timing matters too. We sent the email as soon as the fix was live and tested. Waiting would have let the moment pass. People forget why they left, and a late apology feels like noise.

The small discount code was optional, but it gave people a reason to act now instead of later. It also acknowledged that the client's mistake had cost them time. That gesture turned a problem into a small win.

The Bigger Picture: Own Your Customer Contact

This work was part of a larger project to move the client's email marketing in-house. Before, they used a third-party email tool that limited design options and kept the customer list on someone else's platform. Plain text, boring layout, no real control.

We built an email system into their admin panel. Branded templates, drag-and-drop blocks, product cards pulled live from inventory, discount codes generated and tracked in one place. Everything in the same system that runs their orders and customer records.

The win-back email was the first real campaign sent through the new system. It proved the tools worked and gave the client confidence to run future campaigns without depending on outside software.

Owning your customer contact means you can act fast when something breaks. You do not need to export a list, log into another tool, and hope the send works. You see the problem, pull the data, write the message, and send it, all in one place.

What This Means for Your Business

Bugs happen. Systems break. When they do, your first job is to fix the problem. Your second job is to tell the people who were affected that it is fixed.

Most businesses stop at step one. They repair the system and move on. The customers who were turned away never hear from them again. Those are lost orders you could have saved.

A win-back email takes an hour to write and a few minutes to send. The return is real. People who already tried to buy from you once are more likely to convert than cold leads. They just need to know the problem is solved.

If you are still using third-party email tools that do not connect to your customer data, you are making this work harder than it needs to be. The time you spend exporting lists, switching between systems, and working around design limits is time you could spend running your business.

Next Step

If your customer contact lives in scattered tools and you want to bring it in-house, start with our calculator to see what it costs to build a system that works the way you do. Or contact us to talk through what you need.

Next steps

Let's design the system your business runs on.

Thirty minutes on how your business runs. You leave with a plan, the package that fits and a fixed quote within days. Most businesses start with Scale, from $3,000, with the first month of the Growth care plan free.